A claymorphic-style scene showing a soft trash bin filled with broken budgeting tools, contrasted with a glowing neon green budgeting interface. A black-and-white figure steps away from the trash toward the clean dashboard, in a soft, rounded, playful environment.

Why Most Budgeting Advice is Trash (Here’s What Works)

Let’s talk budgeting.

You’ve probably heard the usual advice before:

“Cut out coffee”

“Cancel Netflix”

“Stop eating out entirely”

And honestly? Most of that advice is trash. Not because saving money is a bad thing, but because this kind of advice misses the point.

If you’re on the path to FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early), you already know the end goal: freedom. But here’s what they don’t tell you: if the journey feels miserable, you’re way more likely to quit halfway through.

So here’s how I think about budgeting and what actually works.


1. Stop Depriving Yourself of What You Enjoy

This one’s huge. Cutting out everything you enjoy in the name of “discipline” will backfire. It’s like trying to sprint a marathon — you’ll burn out fast.

Love your $5 coffee? Cool, keep it.

I get that $5 daily adds up; we’ve all done the math. But if that one coffee gives you motivation, clarity, or just a moment of peace in your morning, that’s worth something. What’s not worth it is saving $150 a month only to overspend later out of frustration.

Instead of saying “no more joy”, say “what can I cut that I won’t miss?”

Balance matters. FIRE isn’t about being cheap; it’s about being smart.


2. Focus on High-Impact Savings

Here’s where most people mess up: they’ll argue over buying brand-name toothpaste while ignoring that they’re overpaying $600 every month on rent or car payments.

The key to smarter budgeting? Go after the big wins:

  • Rent or housing: Can you move somewhere cheaper or get roommates short-term?
  • Car: Can you drive something more affordable or refinance your loan?
  • Subscriptions: Cancel the ones you don’t actually use.
  • Food: Cook at home more, meal prep once a week, and stop letting groceries go bad in your fridge.

Cutting one big expense can save you more than 100 small ones combined, with way less mental strain.


3. Buy Non-Perishables in Bulk

Here’s a simple trick most people overlook.

Stuff like tissues, toilet paper, rice, pasta, soap, toothpaste, these things don’t expire and are way cheaper when you buy in bulk. It’s a one-time purchase that saves you money for months.

If you’re serious about budgeting, you shouldn’t be buying a 4-pack of toilet paper every week like it’s 2012. Go to Costco or Amazon and stock up. Set it and forget it.

It’s not glamorous advice, but it works.


4. Build a Budget Around Your Priorities, Not Restrictions

Forget the idea that budgeting is about saying “no” to everything. The real move? Saying “yes” to what matters most.

Start with these questions:

  • What do I actually value?
  • What are the essentials I need to live and grow?
  • Where can I cut without it affecting my quality of life?

Build your budget around those answers. That way, it stops being something you dread and starts becoming something that gives you control.


5. Use Tools That Make Budgeting Effortless

I’m a spreadsheet person, but if you aren’t, don’t feel bad about it.

Use apps like:

  • YNAB (You Need A Budget) – hands-down the best for hands-on budgeting
  • Mint (free, decent if you’re starting)
  • Copilot or Monarch Money if you want something prettier

Budgeting only works if you can stick to it. Don’t force yourself into something that feels like a chore. Use tools that work for you, not against you.


Final Thoughts

If your budgeting system makes you miserable, you’re doing it wrong.

This journey to financial independence isn’t just about numbers. It’s about designing a life you want to live, and that means finding a balance between discipline and joy.

Cut the fat, not the flavor. Save smarter, not harder. Budget in a way that gives you freedom, not frustration.

The FIRE Fastlane isn’t about suffering your way to $10 million; it’s about building a system that works long-term.

I am on a mission to get to $10 million by the age of 40. Right now I am 22. See here for why I want to get there.

Follow along in my journey and let’s get there together!


Comments

2 responses to “Why Most Budgeting Advice is Trash (Here’s What Works)”

  1. r1r8m8 Avatar
    r1r8m8

    I agree actually. When I sign up for a Netflix subscription, I sign up for one month every now and then. I find out shows I actually want to watch, and then only do I go and click purchase.

    Personally, I feel that way I’m not wasting my money and time.

    Plus, it feels more rewarding.

    1. The FIRE Fastlane Avatar
      The FIRE Fastlane

      That’s a really good strategy. This way, you are not wasting money on Netflix when you are not watching it.